Name: Smithtown Inn
Address: 880 West Jericho Turnpike Smithtown,West Jericho Turnpike, Commack, Commack, Commack, 11787, United States of America
Rating: 2

Smoke-free property

General

Hairdryer

Shower

Rooms

Wi-Fi

Internet access

Internet

Free parking

Parking

Location

At the hotel

Room amenities

Caleb Smith State Park

Blydenburgh County Park

Long Island MacArthur Airport

Republic Airport

Westchester County Airport

Francis S. Gabreski Airport

John F. Kennedy International Airport

LaGuardia Airport

New Haven Airport

Metropolitan Museum of Art

Central Park

American Museum of Natural History

Museum of Modern Art (MoMA)

Rockefeller Center

Broadway

Times Square

Brooklyn Bridge

High Line

Smithtown Inn

Commack

For a non-smoking hotel, the room reeked of smoke.  The stained carpeting,  the broken curtain hooks, were indicitvie to the level of disregard of mainainence.  The bathroom was a break from the disrepair of the bedroom,,, having been recently upgraded nicely.  Our encounter with the one staff member was good.  She helped us as best as she could with our needs.

Run away, as fast as you can.

My companion and I made the mistake of stopping here. The place even looks nice on the outside, at least at night with its blue lighting on white walls, but beware, that's the nicest thing here...the outside.

So we stopped in, called first to confirm, and were accosted by the miserable employee behind the counter. Apparently this sleazy hotel has rooms by the 3-4 hours, and this genius employee I believe was insinuating that my friend and I were a prostitute and a customer when he told me the price for a "couple hours, no more than four". We wanted two beds for a reason, and only wanting to rest around 6-8 hours before we had to finish our lengthy journey the next day, we were expecting the price listed online. Of course we were very loudly and rudely told to "READ THE HOTEL RULES" as he pointed to the sign on the window protecting him from the harm his attitude could bring him one of these days. He seemed bothered that we wanted it for more than the up-to-4 hour rate, but we were exhausted.

As I agree and hand over my credit card, he dials his cell phone to talk to someone in another language, throws the card and slip under the little slot, and gosh I can tell this place is going to be great already.

The worn carpet hallway looks like it had been swept instead of vacuumed. We get to the room, the beds were probably pieces of plywood covered by sheets, so stiff I found the floor to be softer, and of course, couldn't sleep no matter how much I so desperately needed it. I tried watching the undersized television with a remote that didn't work.

We were so happy to leave the next morning. What was I thinking being a contributor to TripAdvisor and not consulting it beforehand?

Dirty, uncomfortable, rude, miserable mistake...

It was coldish and the room heater didn't work. They said they fixed it and they didn't. The basics wee there but absolutely uncomfortable in every respect. I would give it 0 stars if I could.  The other negative reviews are right on. 

Agree with the disgusting and...

In spite of terrible reviews, we found this hotel to be clean and adequate for our one night stay.  The hallway was clean as was the room; the bed was comfortable; the bath towels were fairly thick.  We even got soap and shampoo-- no shower caps.  The room had a small refrigerator and microwave.  A candy and soda dispenser were in the lobby but no tea or coffee. Wi-fi was free and there were a number of tv stations.

Although this is a one or,at most, a two star motel, the price was moderate and we did not encounter any of the negatives listed by others.  The staff is aloof and not outgoing.  However, when we asked for another pillow, the housemaid looked leery, but brought us one immediately.

Sparse but Decent hotel

This place is not meant for anyone with the slightest amount of dignity. Me and my girlfriends booked a room last minute here for a friends wedding and the minute we walked in the door the women started screaming at us that we couldn't stay there. Apparently we were too young and would cause trouble (we are in our mid twenties.) Needless to say, once we finally got our room we realized that this was not a place for common folk. There are condoms in the vending machines, and the rooms are rented by the hour.

Smithtown Inn

Main amenities of the hotel

Location

Available rooms

Location

Description of the hotel

What other amenities are there?

Policies

Check-in terms and conditions

Additional information

Payment